Posted by Joe on August 04, 2000 at 01:36:38:
In Reply to: Re: Djakuju mamko, za ukrajinske z'ytja, to Ihor posted by Ihor on August 03, 2000 at 13:40:43:
: : :Pre Lemko a Ihor od Jovshka
: Po shto, Pane, tak lubytie i hvalitie Madiaruv, bulshe jak sebe-Rusyna, ked' v nachali nasheho stolietia ne pozostalo zhadnej jednej shkolki rusynskoj na calym Pudkarpaciu, a v cerkovi vshytko pravilosia v jazyku madiarskim, a z nasheho jazyku poprostu pany kpili, bo panuv -Rusynov juzh nie bylo, a jak byl pan-Rysyn, to gorshy voroh dlia rysynov jak Madiar.
: RE: Ja hovorjiu o typyrishnych Madiaroch. Ja nehovoriu o Madiaroch do r.1945. Alebo nerozumijete po nashomu,
Ihor:Ну як з Вами розмовляє, мабуть розуміє.
RE: Well don’t you think that you are presumptuous. Let, Mr.Lemko to speak for himself. Are you his spokesman? Well, I have to accept the reality that Het’man-Kerivnyk is always Het’man-Kerivnyk irrespective of location, time or political environment. Het’man-Kerivnyk has to have more rights than others.
: alebo majete Bolshevicku psychologiu , chomu boch sia nechudovav. Bolsheviky hovoryly: Kto nyje z namy je proty nam! A natomto vybudovaly Gulag, Holodomor, Stalinskyj terror. Pudkarpatia bolo sojedyneno s Sovietskou Ukrainou na Stalinskym terrori. A Vy Ukrainski Nacionalisty a Ukarjinsky Bolsheviky budujete Sobornu Ukrainu na tomto terrori.
Ну-мо, чекаю на розповідь про "український терор".
RE: I spoke about the terror introduced by Stalin’s regime, some major parts of it are as follows:
(1) Anexation of Subcarpathia to USSR and its incorporation into Soviet Ukraine.
People of this region responded to the Stalin’s injustice and terror by voting for restoration of its historical self-governing status in 1991. Kiyev’s response was “skasuvaty”, though 78% voted for self-rule in Subcarpathia. If this was not democratic vote and, therefore it is not valid, the vote for Samostijna Ukraina was not democratic either, because it occurred in the same time under the same conditions as the vote for self-rule.
(2) Stalin’s regime abolished Rusyn’s nationality and proclaimed that all Rusyns will be Ukrainians. The Ukrainian Bolsheviks officially declared this policy in 1924. As of today (8/3/2000) this policy is still valid in Ukraine.
This policy of terror, no self-rule, no Rusyn nationality was introduced by Stalin. Whether you like it or not, the fact is that current politicians of Ukraine have been keeping this Stalin’s policy alive in Samostijna Ukraina towards the Rusyns for almost ten years. Your twist of words “ukrains’kyj teror” is stupid but what one can expect from a Het’man-Kerivnyk.
: Mnoho shtastia a zato Ukraina tak procvitaje v zhobroti. Podla Vashej logiky Nemecko typyrj nyje demokratichnou derzhavou bo do 1945 roku maly fashizm a do 1989 v Vostochnyj Nimechyni sovietskoho typu socialism.
Ihor:Отже правильно я зрозумів... Вам не хочеться, щоб русини були незалежними чи автономними, Вам просто хочеться когось побагатішого підшукати, з ким брататися.
RE: You think that you understand too much. Keep thinking in that way. We witnessed in this century that the Great Slavic Brothers “Bratavut’sia” and generate "zhobrotu". I want that Rusyns in Subcarpathia would have a decent life. I wan the population on other site of Carpathian Mountains (Galicia) to have also a decent life because a regional development is typical for a successful economy. And Het’mans in Kiyev have no right to interfere with normal development and progress in the land of Rusyns.
: Rusyn kidj zdurije a pereminyt'sia na Ukraincia rozum stratyt'.
Ihor: Тобто на мадяра можна, на напівсловака як Ви можна, а на українця не можна?
RE: No, Rusyns should stay as Rusyns. Since Hungarians, Slovaks, Poles and Ukrainians are neighbors, they have to learn the languages of these neighbors and understand their cultures.
: Faktom je shto typyrj Madiary mavut' najliberalnishu polytyku k menshynam v Europi.
Ihor: Швейцарію забули. Фінляндію. Ну і так далі.
RE: I would mention Ukraine as well if there were some positive developments. Why shouldn’t be Hungarian progress mentioned? Is this because Ukraine cannot get out of the Bolshevik ailment?
:Nadijmesia shto nyzdurivut' jak dakoly y nybudut' konkurovaty v idiotizme s Ukrainskymy Nazionalistamy y Bolshevikamy.
Ihor: Ярмами як з кулемета стріляєте..
RE And you don’t? You are trying to denigrate anything which in your paranoid Het’man thinking can be potentially perceived as a danger for Ukraine. This Het’man’s psychological environment is a true danger for Ukraine. Well, it is costly but apparently you have to learn it in a hard way.
Ihor: І чогось більшовиків з великої лтери пишете. Нєхарашо
RE: Because they are too representative in current Ukraine reflected in pattern of thinking and that is very “Necharasho”..
P.S. If I write in Rusyn, Ihor, you should answer in Rusyn or English.