Back to the Rusyn issue!

ADVERTISEMENT
Borys Kosarev: Modernist Kharkiv, 1915-1931 at The Ukrainian Museum
Borys Kosarev: Modernist Kharkiv, 1915-1931 at The Ukrainian Museum thru May 2, 2012


[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Brama Survey Comment Board ] [ FAQ ]

Posted by Zmiy Mamay on April 19, 2000 at 23:06:22:

Hi!

I beg your pardon but i'd like to come back to the discussion about the Rusyns! I'm Ukrainian from the Central Ukraine (from Kyivs'ka Oblast'). I've never learned any Rusyn language (some people claim that such a language exists) but when I read some pieces of the Rusyn poetry i could understand 90% of it!!!!! Isn't it surprising?! Historically Karpats'ka Ukrayina formed a common state with the rest of Ukraine only for a very short period of time (for about 80 years) during the times of Kyivan Rus' (of course before it joined Ukraine in 1944). But that poetry, as the author claimed, was not written in Ukrainian!!!!! For me it was as if I had been reading Ukrainian! My question is: How could people who almost never lived together speak almost the same language???? And please, don't argue, that Russian and Ukrainian are very close languages as well!!!! Russians that did not learn Ukrainian CANNOT understand it (at least 60% of it)!! But a Ukrainian who has never learned Rusyn CAN understand it!

I make several conclusions:

1. Rusyns and Ukrainians are ethnicly the SAME people.
2. The Ukrainian language which is very close to what we speak now existed back in the Medieval times (because Rusyn and Ukrainian are very close)
3. The Rusyn issue is clearly political. It'd would be advantageous for the enemies of Ukraine to divide her into several parts (the smaller and weaker the better!)
4. I'm proud of being Ukrainian! But sometimes I'd be happy If people call me Rusyn - my historical ethnic name!!!!!


Follow Ups:

  • Re: Back to the Rusyn issue! Response to Zmiy Mamay. Joe 04/30/00 (2)
  • Re: Back to the Rusyn issue! Response to Zmiy Mamay. Ihor S. 05/01/00 (1)
  • Re: Back to the Rusyn issue! Response to Zmiy Mamayto Ihor S.. Joe 05/02/00 (0)
  • Re: Back to the Rusyn issue! Maryellen Tobiasiewicz 04/29/00 (0)
  • Re: Back to the Rusyn issue! Stefan 04/27/00 (1)
  • Re: Back to the Rusyn issue! Andrew 05/02/00 (0)
  • Re: Back to the Rusyn issue! Questions John 04/22/00 (2)
  • Re: Back to the Rusyn issue! Questions to Zmiy Mamay. John 04/25/00 (0)
  • Re: Back to the Rusyn issue! Questions to Zmiy Mamay. John 04/25/00 (0)
  • Re: Back to the Rusyn issue! Odesit 04/20/00 (2)
  • Re: Back to the Rusyn issue! Vasyl 04/21/00 (1)
  • Re: Back to the Rusyn issue! Odesit 04/24/00 (0)

    Post a Followup

    Name:
    E-Mail:

    Subject:

    Comments:

    Optional Link URL:
    Link Title:


    [ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Brama Survey Comment Board ] [ FAQ ]