News from and about Ukraine & Ukrainians: Ukrainian Community Press Releases
BRAMA
  UKRAINEWSTAND
Home - NEWS - Weather - Biz - Sports - Press - Calendar - Classifieds

  УКРАІНОВИНИ
Home - НОВИНИ - Погода - Ділове - Спорт - Прес - Календар - Оголошення



getLinks(); ?>

UkraiNEWStand BRAMA Press News UKR News ENG News RUS News GOV'T TV/Radio Journals Newsletters World Kiosks
Thu, March 28, 08:35 EDT
Main
  • BRAMA Press
  • Submit press releases here

  • BRAMA Home
  • BRAMA's UkraiNewstand

  • Search

  • full search
  • NEWS
     ·  Regional-National-Int'l
     ·  Politics/Elections
     ·  Business
     ·  Diaspora/Community
     ·  Issues/Health
     ·  Education
     ·  Arts/Culture
     ·  Religion
     ·  Sports
     ·  Travel
     ·  BRAMA Press
    Forums
  • News & Politics BB (Chat)
  • Nova Khvylia BB
  • Traditions BB
  • Travel BB
  • Business Connections BB
  • E-mail Lists

  • Features
     ·  Politics/Elections
     ·  History of Ukraine
     ·  Ukrainian Traditions
     ·  Ukrainian Shops

    [BRAMA Client Websites]
    places to visit

    Survey
    What will L.Kuchma's fate be under the Yushchenko presidency?
    Same as Ceausescu
    Exile in Russia or elsewhere
    Prosecution and jail in Ukraine
    Immunity from prosecution in Ukraine
    Pardoned by Yushchenko
    Other
  • [Results & comment board] ...
  • Horoscope
    Horoscope (Ukr1251 only):


    DISCLAIMER:The contents of press releases on this website represent solely the positions of their respective authors and organizations. BRAMA neither endorses nor disapproves of the views expressed therein. BRAMA retains all final rights as to what may or may not appear on these pages.


    [ TOP]

    BRAMA News and Community Press

    BRAMA, Mar 4, 2004, 3:00 pm ET

    OP-ED

    February 19, 2004

    VOA Ukrainian service cuts
    Ihor Gawdiak

    In a recent op-ed piece in the New York Times Secretary of State Colin Powell indicated that the Bush administration's first foreign policy resolution in 2004 is "to expand freedom," and to "support [its] consolidation in many new but fragile democracies. Surely the administration's list would include Ukraine, a country that is vital to the strategic interests of the United States and Europe. This former Soviet republic of 48 million, once the world's third largest nuclear power, now stands at a most critical crossroads, but judging by the recent actions of a crucial US government agency, the US is about to make a big foreign policy mistake.

    Just how fragile the situation is in Ukraine was clearly explained last month in a Washington Post editorial which cautioned that the country's president, Leonid Kuchma, "appears to be looking for ways to curtail Ukraine's democracy so that he can prolong his own hold on power when his term expires this year." Linking Kuchma to "corruption," "strong-arm tactics," "serious human right violations" and running an "economy warped by clans of oligarchs," the Post further wrote that his aim is to "neutralize the country's most popular leader, Victor Yushchenko, who, polls say, would win the next presidential election if it were fairly held."

    As the Post concluded in its editorial, "[f]reedom could be consolidated this year in Ukraine or slip away," and that the outcome very much depends on the actions of this administration.

    The US Broadcasting Board of Governors (BBG) oversees all of the US government's non-military international broadcasting activities. On February 3 it became known that the BBG decided to implement an earlier decision to cut US international radio broadcasts to Central and Eastern Europe. However, it is difficult to understand why the BBG chose at this critical time to reduce broadcasts to Ukraine, where they are considered by many to be a much needed counterbalance to the country's mostly government-controlled media.

    Last February when the cuts were originally announced, BBG Chairman Ken Tomlinson wrote that broadcasts will be eliminated or curtailed to "democracies of Eastern Europe where free speech is practiced and where the process of joining the NATO alliance is under way." Unfortunately, this statement alone raises the question to what extent Mr. Tomlinson and other BBG members are familiar with the situation in Ukraine. Although Ukraine has voiced its intention of joining NATO, its record on free speech is dismal indeed. The BBG has either not read or does not believe our own State Department's Annual Human Rights Report or any of the countless other resources that describe Ukraine's severely restricted media environment and that rate President Kuchma among the top ten enemies of the press. The BBG also either doubts or has chosen to ignore the urgings of Ukraine's opposition leader, Victor Yushchenko, who during a visit to Washington last February pleaded with administration officials to leave US government radio broadcasts to Ukraine intact.

    One of the US government's broadcast services affected by the cuts is the Voice of America (VOA). VOA director David Jackson sent a (BBG-inspired?) memo that calls for reducing VOA Ukrainian broadcasts by half, beginning March 1, 2004. The service is to "retool its programming and expand its multimedia capabilities," presumably to include television and the Internet. While catch words like "retool" and "multimedia" might have an attractive ring to them, Mr. Jackson and apparently the BBG have ceased to take into account the fact that in a country where the average monthly salary is still around $60, few people have access to the Internet. Similarly, in order to get television programming on the air in Ukraine, the US must depend on Ukrainian State TV or channels owned by oligarchs aligned with President Kuchma. Given this reality, it is therefore highly unlikely that the US will get any TV program on the air in Ukraine that, even if balanced, could in any way be critical of the country's government. And what would be the point of VOA doing a TV program if it could not include any opposition voices or a healthy debate of Ukraine's problems? Whom would our efforts--funded by US taxpayers--be serving? As for the Internet, a better approach for Mr. Jackson and the BBG to take would be to complement, and not supplant, existing VOA radio programming, which remains more widely accessible to Ukrainians.

    As Mr. Jackson and presumably the BBG assure us, however, VOA's Ukrainian Service "will be well positioned to provide full multi-media coverage of this year's presidential elections, both in the United States and Ukraine...." What does "well positioned" mean in this context? By the looks of it, it means that the BBG would like to be able to report back to Congress that VOA's Ukrainian Service has gone "multi-media." However, what the BBG probably won't mention is that in order to be able to experiment with political television and the Internet it will have to decimate VOA Ukrainian radio programming, which happens to be the one vehicle that has proven itself effective in penetrating Ukraine's restricted media environment.

    The BBG might counter that VOA is not the only US media outlet that broadcasts to Ukraine. The other one is Radio Liberty (RL) but that service has also sustained some cuts. More unfortunate, however, is that its programming has just been dropped from its FM affiliate network in Ukraine, relegating its presence mostly to shortwave. Coincidentally, the network that carried RL programming on FM in Ukraine had just come under new management. Its new boss is said to be an associate of President Kuchma's Chief-of-Staff.

    VOA's FM affiliate network in Ukraine, unlike RL's, is somewhat more diversified in that it consists of stations that are not under a central management structure. This might help it survive on FM airwaves a little longer, but as opposition forces in Ukraine point out, efforts to muzzle the country's remaining independent media outlets ahead of the presidential elections in October, have really just begun (the campaign does not start until May). And, if VOA, like RL, ends up getting kicked off FM airwaves in Ukraine, there will all the more reason to strengthen the presence of both broadcasters on shortwave -- a medium that has proven it can go far in penetrating the high walls built by regimes afraid of a free and open press. Cutting back on US international radio transmissions like VOA only helps rulers like Leonid Kuchma to keep those walls in place.

    The fact that the BBG seems to have somehow missed all of this, and that it is currently investing monies and human resources into projects that, unlike radio, will have little or no impact in a restricted media environment like Ukraine's raises some serious questions as to whether an appointed, part-time body of what appears to be a group of domestic media executives with limited foreign policy backgrounds can effectively run the US international broadcasting establishment. The BBG's own website (www.bbg.gov) notes that one of its members "helped launch Fox News Sunday" and worked as a vice president for a cosmetic, toiletries and fragrance association foundation-such "qualifications," frankly, pretty much speak for themselves…

    Under current law the BBG exists an independent body, but its decisions should at least be in line with the administration's New Year's resolutions. If anything, US radio broadcasts to Ukraine should be increased rather than diminished.

    Should anyone still doubt the gravity of the situation in Ukraine, the statements made by Ukrainian opposition leader Yushchenko on February 18, 2004, are well worth noting: "Ukraine has turned into a lawless and undemocratic state." ... "I think that only the people who do not know what the Voice of America is and how important the position of this radio station is for providing objective and timely information to the people of Ukraine can make such [a] decision," ... "taking the latest developments at Radio Freedom [i.e. Liberty] ... into consideration, it becomes clear that this is how independent mass media are [currently] being pressured and persecuted."

    [Source: these excerpts were taken directly from the English version of www.razom.org.ua - the website of Mr. Yushchenko's political party "Our Ukraine."]

    Ihor Gawdiak is President of the Ukrainian American Coordinating Council.

    Letter to U.S. Secretary of State Colin Powell

    February 16, 2004

    The Honorable Colin Powell

    Dear Sir:

    In a recent op-ed piece in the New York Times you indicated that the Bush administration's first foreign policy resolution in 2004 is "to expand freedom," and to "support [its] consolidation in many new but fragile democracies." Any list of today's fragile democracies is likely to include Ukraine -- a strategic former Soviet republic of 48 million and once the world's third largest nuclear power -- that now stands at a most critical crossroads.

    Just how fragile the situation is in Ukraine was underscored last month by a Washington Post editorial which cautioned that its president, Leonid Kuchma, "appears to be looking for ways to curtail Ukraine's democracy so that he can prolong his own hold on power when his term expires this year." Linking Mr. Kuchma to "corruption," "strong-arm tactics," "serious human right violations" and running an "economy warped by clans of oligarchs," the Post further writes that his aim is to "neutralize the country's most popular leader, Victor Yushchenko, who, polls say, would win the next presidential election if it were fairly held."

    As the Post concluded in its editorial, "[f]reedom could be consolidated this year in Ukraine or slip away," and that the outcome may just depend on you. This raises the following point:

    The US Broadcasting Board of Governors (BBG), which oversees all of the US government's non-military international broadcasting activities, announced last week that it decided to implement an earlier decision to cut US international radio broadcasts to Central and Eastern Europe. It is difficult to understand why the BBG chose at this critical time to reduce broadcasts to Ukraine, where they are considered by many to be a much needed counterbalance to mostly government-controlled media. If anything, the number of radio broadcasts should be increased.

    Last February, when the cuts were originally announced, BBG Chairman Ken Tomlinson wrote that broadcasts will be eliminated or curtailed to "democracies of Eastern Europe where free speech is practiced and where the process of joining the NATO alliance is under way." Unfortunately, this statement alone raises the question to what extent Mr. Tomlinson and other BBG members are familiar with the situation in Ukraine. Although, Ukraine has voiced some intentions to join NATO, the situation concerning free speech is dismal indeed. BBG members should have looked at the State Department's Annual Human Rights Report or any of the countless other resources that describe the severely restricted Ukrainian media environment and rate Ukraine's President Kuchma among the top ten enemies of the press. They should have also known that Ukraine's opposition leader, Yushchenko, during a visit to Washington last February pleaded with administration officials to leave US government radio broadcast to Ukraine intact.

    One of the US government's broadcast services affected by the cuts is the Voice of America (VOA). According to a (BBG-inspired?) memo by VOA director David Jackson a (BBG inspired?) beginning with March 1, 2004, VOA Ukrainian is to cut its radio broadcasts by half, and "retool its programming and expand its multimedia capabilities," presumably to include television and the Internet. While catch words like "retool" and "multimedia" might have an attractive ring to them, Mr. Jackson, and apparently also the BBG, ceased to take into account that with television, in order to get its programming on the air in Ukraine, the US depends on Ukrainian State TV or channels owned by oligarchs aligned with President Kuchma. Given this reality, it is therefore highly unlikely that the US will get any TV program on the air in Ukraine that, even if balanced, could be in any way critical of the country's government. And what would be the point of VOA doing a TV program, if it could not include any opposition voices or a healthy debate of Ukraine's problems? And, as far as the Internet is concerned, a better approach for Mr. Jackson and the BBG might have been to have it complement, and not supplant, existing VOA radio programming, which remains widely accessible to Ukrainians. Mr. Jackson and the BBG should know that in a country in which the average monthly salary is still around $60 few people have access to the Internet.

    As Mr. Jackson, and, presumably, by extension, the BBG, assures us, however, VOA's Ukrainian Service "will be well positioned to provide full multi-media coverage of this year's presidential elections, both in the United States and Ukraine...." What does "well positioned" mean in this context? By the looks of it, it means that the BBG would like to be able to report back to Congress that VOA's Ukrainian Service has gone multi-media. However, what the BBG probably won't mention is that in order to be able to experiment with television and the Internet it had to decimate VOA Ukrainian radio programming, which happened to be the one vehicle that had proven itself effective in penetrating Ukraine's restricted media environment. Leaving broadcasts to Ukraine at their current level would not even require additional resources. All the BBG would have to do is use existing ones more wisely.

    Mr. Secretary, I know that as an ex-officio member of the BBG you have significant influence over this otherwise independent body. I urge you to use this influence to have the BBG revisit the issue of cuts in radio programming to Ukraine. And I hope that you will agree that this would be in line with the administration's New Year's resolution.

    Sincerely,

    Ihor Gawdiak
    President, Ukrainian American Coordinating Council



    Copyright © 1997-2011 BRAMA, Inc. All rights reserved.
    The images and information contained in BRAMA News and BRAMA Press reports may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the prior written authority of BRAMA and/or author/photographer. The views and opinions of authors expressed on Brama.com do not necessarily state or reflect the views of Brama - Gateway Ukraine or its officers, directors or associates.


    * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

    More BRAMA Press Releases -- Click Here
    Comments and observations about this article and other news
    may be posted to the BRAMA News & Politics Comment Board

     

    Ukraine video timeline: a year of protests and violence. Daily Telegraph 2/21/2015


    Nadiya Savchenko's speech in Basmanny Court, Moscow, 10.02.2015 (Voices of Ukraine)


    Joe Biden: Don’t tell us. Show us, President Putin. 2/7/2015 Munich Security Conference


    Speech by President of Ukraine at the Munich Security conference Feb 7 2015


    #FreeSavchenko video by Adriana Luhovy [Twitter storm Jan 26 2015]


    FREE NADIYA SAVCHENKO

    FREE NADIYA SAVCHENKO
    Twitter storm day Jan 26 2015


    Live map of Ukraine

    Ukraine Today TV LIVE on Youtube


    Live map of Ukraine

    Live map of Ukraine


    Timothy Snyder: Ukrainian History, European Future. Timothy D. Snyder is a well-known historian and professor of history at Yale University. Speaking at the National University 'Kyiv-Mohyla Academy' on May 15, 2014 on deep connection and strong bonds between Ukrainian and European history.


    Громадське радіо

    Громадське радіо


    Громадське телебачення

    Громадське телебачення


    Facebook Євромайдан

    Facebook Євромайдан


    Happy Kyiv (inspired by Pharrell Williams 'Happy')


    Inauguration of Ukraine's President Petro Poroshenko, June 7, 2014


    The Kyiv Post

    День The Day Newspaper

    Експрес онлайн -- Львів

    Voice of America/Голос Америки

    Mirror Weekly/Дзеркало Тижня

    TVi

    Tochka.net

    Zaxid.net

    Yahoo!
    Foto I |  Foto II |  Slideshow

    World Issues
    Google
     ·  Afghanistan
     ·  Iran
     ·  Iraq
    Yahoo
     ·  Afghanistan
     ·  Iran
     ·  Iraq

    Climate Effects
    Google
     ·  Global Warming
     ·  Hurricanes
     ·  Earthquake
     ·  Bird Flu
    Yahoo
     ·  Climate Change
     ·  Hurricanes
     ·  Earthquake
     ·  Bird Flu

    Nasha knopka Наша кнопка

    SLIDESHOWS
    Yushchenko 2009 (NYC)
    Yushchenko 2008 (NYC)
    Genocide (NYC)
    Rushnyk (NYC)
    more ...

    AUDIO and VIDEO
    Video: OC Yushchenko speech
    Video: Orange Circle Yushchenko
    Video: Heritage Days
    more ...


    Calendar
    more ... ]  


    ** Special: [Ukrainian Holidays and Traditions] [SHOP UKRAINIAN] [POLITICS]

    BRAMA Home -- BRAMA in Ukrainian -- Calendar -- UkraiNEWStand -- Community Press -- Search BRAMA -- Arts/Culture -- Business -- CLASSIFIEDS -- Compute/Software -- Social Issues -- Education -- Fun -- Law -- e-LISTS&BB's -- Nova Khvylia (New Wave) -- SPORTS -- Travel -- Ukraine -- Government -- Diaspora Directory -- Suggest a Link -- Report a dead link -- About BRAMA - WebHosting - Domains - Advertising -- What's New? -- GOOGLE-- Yahoo!
    Copyright © 1997-2011 BRAMA, Inc.tm, Inc. All Rights Reserved.